Ms HB, did you ask your friend what exactly did she see with this dude since she she said "She didn't see all that" when you pointed out this man's gentlemanly behavior? What is she used to?
What did he act like after the date, was he trying to get her in bed after they spent a 3rd date together? Was his attention to her just to get her to give it up, or was it because he genuniely like her.
I've had dates with some doozy's lately, guys that act the gentleman during the date but after it's over they are trying to get some, so it makes me wonder if the date was just a ploy for them. They 'treat me nice so they can get something later and not because they genuniely liked me and wanted my company.
I'm going to trust (based on your advice column) that you are a pretty good judge of what you observed so if you say he is a gentleman and is smitten then chances are he is. Sometimes, the people involved are too close and can't see the behavior. Also if they aren't used to that kind of behavior they may not recognize it.
This is how a guy is supposed to act. Unfortunately and it's sad to say that this behavior has gotten so rare that when we do see a guy acting this way, we notice it and say wow

when it should be regular normal courteous behavior. Used to be way back in the dark ages, guys would stand when a lady entered the room. Nowadays you barely get a guy to give up his seat on a commuter train to a woman in her 8th month of pregnancy...too sad.
