(1) was talking shit just to make her think she was all that in bed and wowing a nikka. You know, some kind of game to keep her sleeping with him;
(2) he was totally into her, the sex with her was icing on the cake, and he is losing his damn mind.
Have any of you ever had that happen... someone asked you that question or told you that you had them sprung?
I’ve had a guy tell me this before, not in those exact words though. I’ve learned to look at what a guy does and not just what he says. He’s got to be "sprung" in more ways than just sexually and show it consistently. If he's doing that, then your (2) choice would most likely fit, otherwise it's probably the first choice you mentioned.